Whole Network Accounting boards of directors Compliance Ethics executive pay SOX strategy

 

Finger pointing: Enron changes nothing

Filed in archive SOX by leon on June 06, 2006

Finger pointing: Enron changes nothing
Check out the piece by Gary Weiss in Salonlinks: Enron changed nothing.



According to Weiss, the only lesson corporations learned was how to point the finger at everyone else. And Sarbanes-Oxley will do nothing to stop it happening again.

"Theoretically, Sarbox would have prevented Enron from happening. Realistically, it wouldn't have done a thing, because an exec with "derring-do" such as Skilling (to quote a February 2001 Business Week cover story) would surely have found a way around it. Not that it would have taken much effort. Sarbox requires, for example, that at least one member of every board audit committee be a "financial expert." It requires that an "internal control report" describe how management has done a good job of tackling all those pesky numbers and checked 'em real good. And, of course, the company must tell us -- immediately! -- about any changes in the "code of ethics" for its chief number crunchers. The cost of complying with these and similar requirements has annoyed some smaller companies, adding to the overall luster of Sarbox when viewed from afar.
"What Sarbox has never done, and never could do, is change corporate behavior, anymore than you can stop a car thief by taping a Do Not Steal sign to the dashboard. Remember that CEOs who are going to pull off a mega-scam like Enron, or even a routine stock swindle or accounting trick, are not going to be deterred by a law book or someone with a stinkin' badge. They have a more pragmatic view of corporate responsibility -- they feel they don't have any. If you listened closely, you heard the Enron management credo at the trial. It is the same philosophy that has been employed by second-story men and Mafia bosses since the dawn of the first proto-scam. It can be summed up as, 'If it's broke, it ain't broke, and anyway it ain't my fault.' "

This is why the calls to overhaul Sarbanes-Oxley won't stop.

The latest is another strong attack from Professor Stephen Bainbridge in TCS Daily.

Bainbridge raises some excellent points.

But the problem for those wanting to dismantle Sarbox boils down to this: while the slums of the rich are still, in the words of Weiss, breeding corporate delinquents, laws like Sarbanes-Oxley are only likely to get more entrenched.





Permalink: Finger pointing: Enron changes nothing
Tags: SarbanesOxley  Enron 

Trackback: http://www.creative-weblogging.com/cgi-bin/mt-tb.pl/23575



Related Entries:

Enron trial begins: some tough choices ahead - 01 February 2006

Enron: a daily guide - 10 February 2006

The seduction of Enron - 14 February 2006

Enron sentence roundup - 17 November 2006

Advertisement


Advertisement


RSSrss   | See all blog subscribe options
Googlegoogle   |   What is RSS?
Yahoo!yahoo
AddthisAddThis Feed Button
BloglinesBloglines
Newsletter

Use the search to look for other interesting posts

 
  • Advertise with us

  • Learn more about our advertising options or email advertising - at - creative-weblogging.com or give Luis a call at +1 (650) 331 8047.


  • Other blogs in the same channel in the Creative Weblogging Network







 
Tagcloud: Accounting boards of directors Compliance corporate crime corporate governance corporate reputation Ethics events executive pay litigation markets regulators risk shareholder activism SOX Sponsored Blog strategy