soxfirst
Vision of the bean counters
Filed in archive Accounting by leon on November 20, 2006
Vision of the bean counters
Last week I wrote in this blog entry about how the world's six biggest accounting firms are now calling for changes that include replacing quarterly financial statements with real-time Internet-based reports, relaxing auditor liability and subjecting all public companies to forensic audits on a random basis.

At the time, I raised the question whether auditors were trying to sneak through changes that would reduce their accountability.

Now more criticism is starting to roll in.




CFO.com describes it as a "Utopian fantasy" and "naive".

"The beancounters are right that few investors or analysts use financial reports as anything more than a rear-view mirror these days. They would prefer forward-looking information including "soft" data on customer relationships, staffing levels and product development.

"But whether such information can be standardised enough to be computer-readable for comparison on company websites is questionable. So is the likely effect on share-price volatility of quasi real-time data: would it make some investors even more short-termist in their outlook? And how would the market cope with the inevitable revisions?"

On the question of dodging liability, the journal is spot on when it suggests that the ghost of Arthur Andersen is still lurking in the background.

"In such an environment, it is no doubt galling that the reporting exercise that firms and their auditors are expected to go through is increasingly seen as meaningless and irrelevant."

The entire exercise raises a number of important questions, says Motley Fool:

"Are the firms posturing to absolve themselves from ferreting out every malfeasance? If so, is that due to a practical evaluation of the state of business practices? After all, with an ever-increasing array of sophisticated financial instruments, accounting no longer involves simply counting the number of widgets in one's inventory. Is there something really broken with routine auditing functions which may occasionally allow malfeasance to pass undetected? Who should bear the cost of policing the current complex capital markets? Who is to blame if things go wrong?"

Plenty to think about there, and we don't yet know the answers.

Permalink: Vision of the bean counters
Tags: Auditing  liability    accounting  corporate  business  bean  vision+bean  bean+counters  firms+calling 
Trackback: http://publish.creative-weblogging.com/publish/mt-tb.pl/42990
img Addthis img Ask img Blinklist img del.icio.us img Digg img Fark img Facebook img Google img Lycos img Ma.gnolia Add this page to Mister Wong Mr Wong img Netscape img Netvousz img Newsvine img Reddit img StumbleUpon img Slashdot img Tailrank img Technorati img Wink img Yahoo

Vote for Vision of the bean counters:

  • Currently 8.67/10
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 9
  • 10
Rating: 8.67 out of 6 vote(s) cast.
 
Subscribe
Share It
RSSrss
See all blog subscribe options
Google google
What is RSS?
Yahoo! yahoo
Addthis Subscribe using any feed reader!
Bloglines Bloglines
Newsletter

TwitterFollow us on Twitter!